"Well that is between you and the Almighty, I suppose." It's none of his business why she is here and not in Bad Place or Good Place or wherever. Who is he even to question? He is not going to call her Eleanor since she seems to be either not capable of or willing to even go by a simple variation of his name, so he will leave it how it is. Humans are like that.

"At least, if I'm understanding things correctly, you will find yourself to be rather less dead than you were when you started." Which, good news or not, he's not entirely sure.